There isn’t one payment processor that is best for every small business.
A retail shop taking cards across a counter has very different needs from a consultant sending invoices, an online store accepting payments through a website, or a business that needs specialized underwriting.
That’s why it makes more sense to start with how your business gets paid rather than starting with a list of payment processors.
Below are several common small-business situations and the types of processors worth comparing for each one.
If Most of Your Customers Pay You in Person
For retailers, salons, repair shops, restaurants, contractors, pop-up vendors, and other businesses that regularly accept payments face-to-face, the payment terminal and point-of-sale experience matter.
You may want to consider:
Square if you want a relatively simple system that combines payment processing, POS software, card readers, and other business tools within one platform.
Helcim if you want in-person processing but also expect to use invoicing, online payments, or a virtual terminal as part of your business.
The important questions are not simply which company has the lowest advertised rate. Think about the equipment you need, how many locations or employees will use it, whether you need inventory or other POS tools, and how much you expect to process each month.
If Your Business Is Primarily Online
An online business may care much less about countertop equipment and much more about checkout, website integration, subscriptions, payment links, and the ability to accept different types of payments.
Stripe is worth comparing for online-first businesses because it offers several ways to accept payments, ranging from simple hosted payment pages to much more customized checkout integrations.
Square can also be worth considering when a business wants online payments along with access to Square’s broader POS and business-management ecosystem.
For an online business, ask yourself how much control you actually need. A highly customizable payment system can be valuable, but it can also be unnecessary if all you need is a straightforward way for customers to pay online.
If You Mostly Send Invoices
Consultants, contractors, professional services, wholesalers, and other businesses often don’t need a traditional checkout counter at all.
They need to send an invoice, collect the payment, keep track of what is still outstanding, and occasionally take a payment over the phone.
That makes tools such as Helcim, Square, and Stax worth comparing.
Rather than choosing based only on a transaction rate, look at the complete workflow:
Can you create and send invoices easily?
Can customers pay from the invoice?
Can you set up recurring payments when needed?
Can you take a payment manually through a virtual terminal?
Can you keep customer and payment records organized?
For an invoice-driven business, the easiest day-to-day system may ultimately matter more than having the longest list of features.
If You Take Payments in Several Different Ways
Many small businesses don’t fit neatly into an “online” or “in-person” category.
A contractor might take a deposit over the phone, send an invoice for the balance, and occasionally accept a card at the job site.
A retailer might have a storefront, an online shop, and occasional off-site sales.
A professional service business might primarily send invoices but still want customers to pay through a website.
In cases like these, it can make sense to compare processors such as Square, Helcim, or Stax that can support more than one way of accepting payments.
The goal is not necessarily to find the processor with the most features. It is to avoid piecing together several different systems when one payment setup can reasonably handle the ways your customers actually pay you.
Ready to Explore Your Options?
Answer 6 quick questions to see which processors may be a good fit for your business.
If Your Processing Volume Is Growing
The processor that works well when a business is small may not always remain the right fit as processing volume increases.
Flat-rate pricing can be attractive because it is easy to understand. But as your processing volume grows, the underlying pricing model deserves more attention.
This is where processors such as Helcim and Stax may become worth comparing with simpler flat-rate platforms.
Look beyond the percentage shown on a pricing page. Consider your average transaction size, monthly processing volume, card mix, monthly fees, equipment costs, and any other charges that affect your total cost of accepting payments.
A slightly more complicated pricing structure can sometimes make sense for an established business—but only if the overall numbers work in your favor.
If Your Business Is Considered Higher Risk
Some businesses have difficulty getting approved by mainstream payment processors because of their industry, chargeback exposure, recurring billing model, processing history, transaction size, or other underwriting factors.
In that situation, applying repeatedly to mainstream processors may not solve the problem.
A specialized provider such as PaymentCloud or Durango Merchant Services may be more appropriate to investigate because these companies work with businesses that require more individualized underwriting.
Higher-risk processing can involve different pricing, documentation, reserve requirements, contract terms, and approval standards, so it is especially important to understand the agreement before opening an account.
The important distinction is that a higher-risk business may need a different type of processor, not simply a different brand.
So Which Payment Processor Should a Small Business Choose?
Start with the way your business operates.
Ask:
- Do most customers pay in person, online, or by invoice?
- Do you need a countertop terminal, mobile reader, or full POS system?
- Do you need recurring billing?
- Do you take payments over the phone?
- Are you primarily selling online?
- How much do you expect to process each month?
- Is your business likely to require specialized underwriting?
- Are you expecting your payment volume or business model to change?
Those answers can eliminate processors that don’t fit before you ever start comparing rates.
That is much more useful than choosing a company simply because it appears at the top of somebody’s “best payment processors” list.
Narrow Down Your Options
Premier Processors is designed to help you start with your business rather than a random list of payment companies.
Our processor-matching tool looks at factors such as your business type, how you accept payments, processing volume, and other requirements to narrow the field to processors that may make sense for your situation.
The goal is not to tell you which processor to choose, but to make the comparison easier by helping you focus on options that are more relevant to how your business actually operates.
We help businesses compare payment processors with clarity and confidence so they can make a more informed choice.